Redshirting kindergarten 20228/3/2023 That kid struggled in school his entire life. It always struck me as (1.) so so unfair to that child, and (2.) sticking their heads in the sand regarding their boy. The parents NEVER had him evaluated, and preferred to pray about it, than actually seek any kind of treatment. I knew that family since their son was 10. Indeed, I knew a family that had a child that was every so clearly afflicted with ADD. To me, it's no more morally wrong then fixing a cleft lip on a baby, or finding out your child has ADHD, but expecting the child to perform like everyone else at school, without any kind of intervention. And then they're on track all through grade school to always be behind. Lots of times, the 'younger' 6 yr olds struggle and are behind. How do I make him see that you sometimes have to give up what you desire in order to do what's right? Thank you in advance! He's also the breadwinner of the family, so what he says pretty much goes. I've tried telling my husband this, but he doesn't seem to think there's anything unethical about this. I would feel much happier if he did okay playing by the rules than excel by cheating. I couldn't genuinely feel proud of my son for outperforming kids a year younger than him. It would give him an unfair advantage over the rest of his classmates. However, the reason I don't want to redshirt is simply because it's morally wrong. I have no doubt that if we redshirt our son, he'll get straight A's and be in gifted programs all through school, win every class competition, be valedictorian, go off to one of HYP, and have a 6-figure-salary by his mid-twenties. Indeed, there are countless studies out there that prove that kids who are older almost always do better. I'm not trying to deny that he'll do much better in school if we wait a year. However, he is insisting that we wait until the Fall of 2022, as this means he will consistently perform better than all of his classmates instead of performing worse than 3 quarters of his classmates, as would probably be the case if we sent him on time. In 2021, our son will turn 5 in the first week of October, which means that he should be starting Kindergarten next Fall. However, this is exactly what my husband wants to do. This is clearly cheating, as it's almost inevitable a child is going to come out on top when being compared to children a year younger than them. This is when the parents of a child born between October and December wait until their child is almost 6 to send them to Kindergarten, so that they will be older than their classmates and have an unfair advantage over them. One example that pertains to our family right now is Redshirting. Success really isn't anything to be proud of if you had to cheat to do it. To me, how you accomplish something is even more important than the accomplishment itself.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply.AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |